Not to be confused with the Spooky Eyes.
The Scary Eyes is a members-only land den item that was first released on October 19, 2012. It is a seasonal item that returns during the Night of the Phantoms and was most recently sold in Jam Mart Furniture.
The Scary Eyes consists of a large gaping crack that is pitch black inside, where a monster's eye(s) or mouth is shown. The visible part of the monster then moves off screen, but later returns to be seen through the crevice. This item comes in nine different varieties.
- This item was previously sold in the Haunted Forest Party from its first release until 2016, in which year it was moved to Jam Mart Furniture.
- One of the varieties shows only a monster's mouth, despite the item being called "Scary Eyes".