Plushies are stuffed animals found in Animal Jam. They are den items, collected as novelties and for enhancing the homes of Jammers. The appearance of a Plushie generally takes form of a playable animal (however, there are quite a few plushies serving as exception) coming in various colors, with visible fastened stitches. For example, Pandas, Wolves, Bunnies, Koala, Monkeys, Tigers, and Deer are available plushies, as of December 2013. Plushies also have a "Rare" form with accesories. These are quite hard to get and are often more valuable than regular ones. New plushies come out whenever a new animal is accessible, or during festivities. Plushies that are brand new are harder to obtain than the traditional plushies. Sometimes there are different variations of a plushie (i.e. orange and green gecko plushies). Originally plushes could only come in one color. (Tigers orange and black, pandas black and white, monkeys purple, bunnies white, etc). All plushies regular sized are generally non-member, however, all giant plushies are exclusive to members only (excluding the Giant Kangaroo Plushie and the Giant Raccoon Plushie).
As previously mentioned, the Journey Book for Crystal Reef and Mt. Shiveer will bring forth a stuffed prize, Crystal Reef has the pufferfish plushie, that puffs up when clicked, and Mt. Shiveer has a red panda plushie. At the Summer Carnival Shop, plushies, giant and regular sized, of pets are sold, along with other marine animals plushies varying in size as well. Finally, giant plushies of land animals can be found in the Diamond Shop, Epic Wonders (the Black Giant Wolf Plushie), and, previously, in the Conservation Museum. These cannot be won in the claw.